Do We Have a Logic Problem?

This past Wednesday, an alert noise on my phone sounded at 6:15 am. The high school posted a substitute job as an “extra certified position.” These jobs are a bit like playing the lottery: you go into school to see what you’ll be doing that day. In other words, to see what you’ve won.

In this case, it turned out to be a full day: five classes in different classrooms throughout the building so teachers could attend meetings. It was at least as physically taxing as it was mentally. Flexibility is an essential requirement. But I always end up feeling like I’ve learned more from the kids than they learn from me.

Especially on this day. I talked to a student who has a real interest in human behavior. He’s been observing the discussions and debates in conjunction with the recent election, and he’s convinced he’s discovered a psychological aliment that has yet to be formally identified. He calls it Logical Processing Disorder, as in the difficulty some people have in applying logic to the real world, especially in abstract situations.

His conclusion is based on several factors he’s observed —

  • Some people seem to struggle with subjects that require analysis.
  • These people rarely ask questions.
  • They seem uncomfortable questioning authority.
  • They tend to accept injustices, seldom calling for change.
  • They tend to dismiss factual corrections to their opinions.

Has he really discovered something? Would this explain a lot of the “cognitive dissonance” in our democracy? And dare I ask: does anyone see themselves in those “symptoms”?

The American Psychiatric Association does publish a “Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders” to classify recognized mental disorders. Maybe Logical Processing Disorder needs to be recognized and included. Especially before the next election.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *